.
Feedback

Poll: Should It Be Harder to Exempt Your Kids from Vaccinations?

Berkeley kindergarten students have more personal belief exemptions for vaccinations than the state average. Private schools account for half of Berkeley's total. A bill in Sacramento would make exemptions harder to get.

When Berkeley public school students return to the classroom on August 29, kids going into kindergarten and the 7th grade will be required to show proof of various vaccinations. The same is true for students at private schools. While school officials use phrases like "no shots, no school" to underscore the message, the reality is not so strict. 

Parents or guardians can obtain an exemption from vaccination requirements for medical reasons or personal beliefs. To get a personal belief exemption (PBE) all a parent needs to do is sign an affadavit in front of a school secretary. Last year, 38 children entered kindergarten in Berkeley’s public and private schools with a personal belief exemption on file.

In Berkeley, private schools tend to have a higher rate to PBEs. With less than a quarter of kindergarten enrollment, Berkeley's private schools account for 50 percent of the PBEs, according to the California Department of Public Health. It's not in Berkeley, but the East Bay Waldorf School in El Sobrante has one of the highest PBE rates in the state with 68 percent. 

A bill in the state legislature aims to make it tougher for parents to get a PBE by requiring an additional signature from a doctor or medical professional. Opponents of the proposed legislation argue that doctors tend to be dismissive of parental qualms about vaccinations. Some public health professionals note that the risk of not vaccinating a child is only acceptable when the vast majority of children are vaccinated and diseases like whooping cough are relatively rare. 

What do you think? Scroll down to take our poll. 

School Kindergarten Enrollment Medical Exemption %Medical Exemption Personal Belief Exemptions %PBE Public Schools Berkeley Arts Magnet 63 0 0 2 3% Cragmont 62 0 0 2 3% Emerson 41 3 7% 0 0 Jefferson  60 0 0 0 0 John Muir 63 1 2% 2 3% Le Conte  58 0 0 1 2% Malcolm X 77 0 0 4 5% Oxford  62 1 2% 2 3% Rosa Parks 64 0 0 5 8% Thousand Oaks 60 0 0 1 2% Washington  84 0 0 0 0 Private Schools American International Montesorri 12 0 0 1 8% Berkwood Hedge 20 0 0 3 15% Black Pine Circle 22 0 0 1 5% Ecole Bilingue De Berkeley 75 0 0 8 11% Montesorri Family School 13 0 0 3 23% School of the Madeleine 31 0 0 1 3% The Berkeley School 27 0 0 0 0 Walden Center and School 13 0 0 2 15% Berkeley Total 907 5 0.5% 38 4.2% California Total 529,400 0.16%
2.39% Source: California Department of Public Health

Want Berkeley school news delivered straight to your inbox? Sign up for our newsletter. 

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Berkeley Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Loading comments ...
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
protests in Washington DC
Speak Out  

0   Recommend J M

protests in Washington DC
actors from Clerks 1 and 2
Speak Out  

0   Recommend J M

actors from Clerks 1 and 2
nick mastick April 28, 2013 at 09:34 pm
Of all the concerns in our society, I put this just about dead last.
Steven Murphy April 17, 2013 at 02:25 am
Hmm. So I think you're telling me I need to add the countdown timers to the long list of BerkeleyRead More idiosyncrasies I need to ignore? I guess can do that. Thanks. --Murph
Alexander Sinclair Merenkov April 15, 2013 at 04:34 pm
This is very interesting. I bicycle and walk a lot around Berkeley. I think i know exactly whatRead More signal is being referred to the walk sign across Bancroft at MLK specifically will reset itself. many of the walk signals rely on induction loops which are loops placed in the ground that can detect Bicycles and Cars when the Bicycles or cars pass over them disrupting the current. You can often see these loops as they look like hexagonal saw cuts in the ground. Anyways the intersection detects traffic with these devices & if it doesn't detect anything then it assumes nothing is there and gives right of way to the major throughway in this case being MLK. So the reason the counter to cross Bancroft resets itself is totally logical because the intersection suspects no one is there and since that side of Bancroft is more or less residential there would be no point in setting that intersection to a timer where it gives priority to one light then the other & switches based on that & not on wether it detects any bicycles or cars passing over the induction loops. Also this is Berkeley and we are rather quirky and always have been so nobody exactly fallows the rules or knows about them its funny how simple crossing the street really is but its anything but simple in reality. Many people choose to jay walk if its safe to do so, this is typical on Shattuck at alston especially and makes sense for efficiency but isn't very safe or lawful. If the hand is flashing/Counting down dont cross!
Janet Scrivener April 6, 2013 at 11:15 pm
Actually, I just saw and spoke to him about an hour ago - the wire sculpture man. He'd moved downRead More Solano a few blocks, opposite Safeway. I asked him if the police had moved him off Colusa. He said he didn't want to talk about it. He wasn't in a very good mood. I told him that people had asked about him on a web local news site. He said, "People want to know how I'm doing? I need a car. I need somewhere to put my stuff in. To get off the streets. I don't want to sit around starving in public." I thought to myself, "Who do I think I am? A Girl Scout leader? Pollyana?" I realized my upbeat, cheery tone was really not what was needed just then. I said I couldn't help him with a car. "People want to know how I'm doing?" he said again. "Tell them that." I said, "I will." I turned to walk away, knowing only too well that the real needs that exist, yes, right here in our lovely, excellent neighborhood, are great and once you start giving you'll find it's difficult to get out of. He did say, "Thank you," as I left. He doesn't look like he's starving. But he's right about being out in public more than he would like to be. As a reasonable human being, I have to ask myself, what sort of person finds himself in that position? Ex con? Mental illness? Mind-blown Vet? Drugs? Alcohol? Incapacitated by an accident? An unforgivable act? Some combination of the above? Jesus did say, "The poor you shall have always with you." What would you do?
P. Park April 4, 2013 at 03:29 am
I agree Shattuck, especially right in front of the fire station is the scariest street around.
Mary April 3, 2013 at 06:45 pm
I am not disabled, but I am terrified of crossing streets nowadays because there are too manyRead More careless and aggressive drivers who act is if red lights, speed limits, and crosswalks either don't exist or don't apply to them. Shattuck in particular has become a nightmare to cross. Sometimes I have counted over 30 cars going by before one stops for the crosswalk. What we need is far more law enforcement - the tickets written would more than pay for the cost of hiring extra officers.